You Can’t Please All 1981 Bhupen Khakhar 1934-2003 Purchased 1996 http://www.tate.org.uk/art/work/T07200

You Can’t Please All 1981 Bhupen Khakhar 1934-2003 Purchased 1996 http://www.tate.org.uk/art/work/T07200 / View full image

Two seminal Indian artists of the twentieth century have captured the international spotlight this year, as the subject of major retrospectives in art centres of the Western-art world. A few weeks ago Indian modernist Nasreen Mohamedi’s exhibition concluded at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, a monographic survey which opened the Met Breuer, The Met’s new venture taking over the New York space formerly occupied by the Whitney Museum of American Art. In the final week of the Mohamedi exhibition, a major retrospective for Bhupen Khakhar, a late-modernist whose impact on Indian art history could be compared to Mohamedi’s, opened in London at the Tate Modern. QAGOMA is fortunate to hold works by both artists as treasured features of the Asian art collection.

Both artists are considered radical figures in the context of Indian art. Mohamedi challenged the male-dominated establishment by eschewing the popularity of iconographic and colourful figuration being made at India at the time, offering a fastidious enquiry into abstraction that she made uniquely her own. While Khakhar, with his experimental approach to planar composition and figuration, made observations of the everyday with an unassuming wit, uncovering provocative themes and taboo subjects, in particular his homosexuality.

Though Mohamedi found little acclaim before her early death at the age of 53 in 1990, her work is now considered a grand contribution to international modernism, and prior to the recent Met Breuer show, the artist was included in documenta 12 in Kassel, Germany in 2007, and has been subject of smaller solo exhibitions in New York as well as at the Tate Liverpool in 2014. The recent exhibition was the result of a collaboration between the Met, the Museo Reina Sofia in Madrid, and the Kiran Nadar Museum of Art in Delhi, whose Director, Roobina Karode, is considered one of the leading specialists on the works of Mohamedi. It included paintings, drawings and photographs, as well as collections of notes and diaries,that offer an insight to the mind of an artist relatively unnoticed during her lifetime, but has been written into art history as an immensely important figure.

Nasreen Mohamedi, India 1937-1990 / Untitled c.1975 / Collection: Kiran Nadar Museum of Art, New Delhi / © Estate of the artist / Image source

Nasreen Mohamedi, India 1937-1990 / Untitled c.1975 / Collection: Kiran Nadar Museum of Art, New Delhi / © Estate of the artist / Image source / View full image

The self-taught Khakhar on the other hand had a profoundly successful career, making a significant impact on the international stage by the 1980s, and attracting the attention of other artists, poets and authors. Famously he befriended Salman Rushdie who wrote him into the 1995 novel ‘The Moor’s Last Sigh’ as the accountant, Khakhar’s vocation prior to becoming a professional artist. Khakhar returned the gesture by creating a portrait of Rushdie now in the collection of the National Portrait Gallery in London. However with the opening of ‘Bhupen Khakhar: You Can’t Please All’ at the Tate Modern, the jury is apparently is still out. While author Amit Chaudhuri painted a personal picture of Khakhar’s humble insights into Indian life in The Guardian, a following article by The Guardian arts writer Jonathan Jones failed to get beyond a comparison to ‘the kind of British painter it (the Tate) would never let through its doors’, fuelling an uproar of responses from the Indian arts community, with comments on The Guardian website from Rushdie himself, as well as a heated response from respected author and critic Geeta Kapur in The Wire.

Bhupen Khakhar, India 1934-2003 / Portraits of my mother and my father going to Yatra 1971 / Oil on canvas / Purchased 1998. Queensland Art Gallery Foundation Grant / Collection: Queensland Art Gallery | Gallery of Modern Ar / © Estate of the artist

Bhupen Khakhar, India 1934-2003 / Portraits of my mother and my father going to Yatra 1971 / Oil on canvas / Purchased 1998. Queensland Art Gallery Foundation Grant / Collection: Queensland Art Gallery | Gallery of Modern Ar / © Estate of the artist / View full image

Khakhar’s Portraits of my mother and my father going to Yatra from 1971 is currently hanging in Gallery 6 in a display which groups some of the pioneering figures of modern and contemporary art in Asia. Painted rather early in his career, the work is a rare representation of Khakhar’s parents. In the background is the Residency Bungalow in Baroda which was Khakhar’s home at the time. The image of his mother was done from a photograph while that of his father was constructed from his imagination and the style of this painting is typical of Khakhar’s works of this period – the intersecting planes and bright colours he continued to apply is immediately apparent, while later works pursued a more expressive approach. Vivid blocks of flat colour are used to divide and compose the painted surface, to articulate particular areas of interest and to provide a simple but active visual structure onto which Khakhar paints his narrative.

The painting draws attention to the humble and intense relationships of love, desire, relationships and work that are characteristic of everyday life. It is contextualised in the current display with works by artists who have also made a major impact to the art history of Asia with similarly simple, yet poignant messages drawn from everyday symbolism, such as China’s Yu Youhan, Cambodian artist Svay Ken, Pakistan’s Aisha Khalid, and the beloved sculpture The skin speaks a language not its own by Bharti Kher, a leading Indian artist of a generation that took great influence from Khakhar.

Queensland Art Gallery Gallery 6 installation view

Queensland Art Gallery Gallery 6 installation view / View full image

The Gallery holds a significant body of photographic works by Nasreen Mohamedi. While they were never created to be exhibited, they are now a celebrated part of her career, capturing the poetry and ethereality at the core of her practice. Mohamedi’s father owned a photographic equipment shop in Bahrain, and this, together with travelling with the artist MF Husain (1915–2011) while he was filming in Rajasthan, inspired Mohamedi to employ the medium as part of her creative exploration. Her photographs are an insight into her broader formal interests while they show a nuanced perspective on the landscape and objects, of fleeting light, dense shadows, the undulating lines in nature, and the rigid geometry of buildings. These photographs made up a considerable section of the recent retrospective, and are valued as forming the material basis of Mohamedi’s formal investigation, an art that brings together the logic and rigour of abstraction and an aspiration toward the metaphysical.

Nasreen Mohamedi, India 1937-1990 / Untitled c.1968 / Gelatin silver photograph on paper / Purchased 2004. The Queensland Government’s Gallery of Modern Art Acquisitions Fund / Collection: Queensland Art Gallery | Gallery of Modern Art / © Estate of the artist

Nasreen Mohamedi, India 1937-1990 / Untitled c.1968 / Gelatin silver photograph on paper / Purchased 2004. The Queensland Government’s Gallery of Modern Art Acquisitions Fund / Collection: Queensland Art Gallery | Gallery of Modern Art / © Estate of the artist / View full image

MOHAMEDI, Nasreen India b.1937 d.1990 Untitled c.1971 Gelatin silver photograph on paper ed. 7/10 21.9 x 36.3cm 21.9 x 36.3cm (comp.) Acc. 2004.272 Purchased 2004. The Queensland Government’s Gallery of Modern Art Acquisitions Fund

MOHAMEDI, Nasreen India b.1937 d.1990 Untitled c.1971 Gelatin silver photograph on paper ed. 7/10 21.9 x 36.3cm 21.9 x 36.3cm (comp.) Acc. 2004.272 Purchased 2004. The Queensland Government’s Gallery of Modern Art Acquisitions Fund / View full image

The recent retrospectives of Mohamedi and Khakhar acknowledge the legacy such figures have made to international art, and reveal aspects of some of the vibrant modernist movements that occurred outside western art centres with celebrations of the careers of two very different Indian artists. One, a self-taught artist known for expressive figural works, who experienced a successful international career and was able to bring conversations about homosexuality to the forefront of Indian art. The other, a woman born in Karachi who travelled to study art as a teenager, known for quiet and deeply introspective works that never reached the acclaim they deserved during her lifetime, but who produced an art with the formal investigation and a revelation of aesthetic possibilities inherent in the world that rivalled any of the modernist mainstream thinking of the time.

Know Brisbane through the QAGOMA Collection / Delve into our Queensland Stories / Read more about Australian Art / Subscribe to QAGOMA YouTube to go behind-the-scenes

Related Stories

  • Read

    Unlocking the collection: Project digitise

    As part of QAGOMA’s Collection Online project, the Gallery joins forces with Queensland University of Technology (QUT) for a new Digital Residency, writes Tonya Turner, that will reveal how digital experiences can best engage virtual and on-the-ground visitors. The residency will break new ground in understanding how visitors engage with art and digital interactives across gallery spaces. Undertaken by QUT’s Associate Professor of Digital Pedagogies, Dr Kate Thompson, the residency also provides a detailed review of existing research into how people use and learn from digital museum experiences. According to Thompson, there is much work to be done in the field. ‘Digital interactions are a powerful way to immerse visitors in an experience that can extend the art in a lot of different ways — there just isn’t a lot of research on it’, she says. Thompson’s planned outcome of the residency is a set of design principles, ‘so if you’d like your exhibit to have a particular impact, you’ll have guidance’. RELATED: European masterpieces digitally enhanced This residency will measure engagement on a custom-built, small-scale virtual tour (created by QAGOMA’s Digital Transformation Manager, Morgan Strong), in which Gallery visitors are invited to partake via their smartphones or other personal devices. The project will start with a handful of interactives, expanding to include more works and tour points as the Gallery digitises more of its Collection; and test how engaging in-person visitors find various digital features, including high‑resolution imagery, map-based explorations, image sliders, essays and other digital content. Among the works on the virtual tour is one of the Gallery’s most popular paintings, Under the jacaranda 1903 by R Godfrey Rivers. Visitors can go deeper into the world of the painting via an image slider and essay. ‘It will be fascinating to see what type of detail people are interested in’, says Thompson, whose team will determine which digital features have visitors hooked. ‘We’ll be able to collect information about what they’re clicking on’, she says. Esteemed Pintupi/Ngaatjatjarra artist Doreen Reid Nakamarra’s Untitled (Marrapinti) 2008 is also part of the tour. This painting is ‘normally displayed flat on a table in the Gallery’, says Thompson, ‘so the high-resolution digitisation allows visitors to pinch and zoom to see the detail in the work’. RELATED: ‘Under the jacaranda’ image slider DELVE DEEPER: The art of R Godfrey Rivers In the international art collection, an interactive map will take visitors on a whirlwind tour of the world. Pinpointing the origins of works by Camille Pissarro, Spencer Gore, John Russell, Edgar Degas, Picasso and Toulouse-Lautrec, the map connects art-lovers to places ‘that can be difficult to imagine from so far away’, says Morgan Strong, allowing ‘more of an appreciation of [a work’s] context and how it was created’. In this way, a visitor can zoom in on Degas’s Trois danseuses a la classe de danse (Three dancers at a dance class) c.1888–90, then take a virtual trip to Paris to map out his artistic neighbours and contemporaries. RELATED: Zoom in on ‘Three dancers at a dance class’ DELVE DEEPER: The art of Edgar Degas The Digital Residency forms part of QAGOMA’s Collection Online digitisation project, which aims to make the Gallery’s entire Collection accessible virtually through photography, 3D imaging, timelapse records of installation and more. Collection Online is the largest component of the QAGOMA Digital Transformation Initiative, a wide-reaching program moving the Gallery towards a digitally integrated future. Tonya Turner is a freelance writer. She spoke to Morgan Strong and Dr Kate Thompson in November 2021. QAGOMA Foundation You can help make our Collection accessible alongside inspiring and thought-provoking digital resources by donating online or contacting Dominique Jones, Philanthropy Manager on (07) 3840 7246. QAGOMA Business Development and Partnerships For details on our Corporate Partnership initiatives, please contact the Gallery’s Head of Business Development and Partnerships, Kylie Lonergan, on (07) 3840 7641 or email kylie.lonergan@qagoma.qld.gov.au. The Queensland Art Gallery | Gallery of Modern Art acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the land on which the Gallery stands in Brisbane. We pay respect to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Elders past and present and, in the spirit of reconciliation, acknowledge the immense creative contribution First Australians make to the art and culture of this country. Featured image: A visitor using QAGOMA’s interactive digital experience to dive deeper into the story of Judy Watson’s tow row 2016 / Photograph: C Callistemon © QAGOMA
  • Read

    Unlocking the collection: Art detectives

    The Collection Online project currently underway at QAGOMA aims to digitally capture every work in the Collection, making them as accessible to the public as possible. Many older works, some of which haven’t been displayed in decades, have been retrieved from the depths of storage and given their moment in front of the camera. When you imagine a conservator at work, you might picture a person wearing a lab coat and gloves, carefully cleaning a sculpture with a cotton swab or using a microscope to adhere a tiny flake of paint. You might picture them in a conservation laboratory, surrounded with scientific equipment and tools of their trade, spending hours preparing a work for its moment in the spotlight. What you might not realise is that along with the skills required to physically repair or prepare a work of art for display, a conservator may also need to be an art detective. Sleuthing through old records and library archives reveals important information about the work and the artist’s intent and by drawing these fragments of information together, both the physical work and its meaning can be restored. It’s usually quite easy to determine how two-dimensional works, like paintings, should hang, but when sculptures or assemblages have multiple parts — and sometimes hundreds — it becomes more complicated. Exhibition change-overs can be hectic and it’s sometimes impossible to create and save installation information systematically, particularly when large installations arrive en masse for exhibitions like ‘The Asia Pacific Triennial of Contemporary Art’ (APT), which are displayed across the two gallery buildings. If an artist installs the work themselves, they may not always record how the pieces fit together, or what their requirements are for future reinstallation in different contexts and spaces (what we call ‘iterations’). In some instances where works have not been installed since the 1980s and 90s — before digital cameras — images of the install process are rare. For example, for one sculptural installation collected in 1982 a handwritten note from the artist instructed installers to ‘unroll the fabric into a whirl’, but for a work made of bamboo and woven wool, and without photos, this was a confusing direction. Another sculpture — Nindityo Adipurnomo’s Introversion (April the twenty-first) — had numerous ‘spare parts’ generously provided by the artist and safely stored — but with insufficient documentation to easily determine what was required for installation and what was not. Without clear instructions or detailed images, works like these have a very real risk of losing their intended physicality and meaning. Curators might also find it challenging to propose them for exhibition because there are too many unknowns. Installing ‘Introversion (April the twenty-first)’ Watch | Installation time-lapse Our photographers are capturing every artwork in the QAGOMA Collection, including works so large that a whole gallery space has been transformed into a photographic studio to accommodate them. Watch as we install Nindityo Adipurnomo’s Introversion (April the twenty-first) 1995-96 To solve these unknowns and ensure the digitisation team can accurately record each work of art, the Collection Online conservator and registrar have spent hours in the Gallery’s records and archives, particularly those held in the QAGOMA Research Library, including catalogues, artists’ files and acquisition records. An archive has also been kept of past exhibitions, which has been a useful source of photos, slides and floor plans that have provided valuable information. For works collected in the era before computers and electronic databases, a hand-drawn mud map or a fax from an artist’s studio with a rough diagram might be the piece of information that helps to solve an installation puzzle. When the paper trail ends, the team is fortunate to be able to draw on the corporate memory of current and former staff members, and even artist’s themselves, who have generously given their time to work through a range of installation and technical questions. All this information is now being recorded — historical records are being scanned, discrepancies clarified, mysteries solved and documentation updated. While the core goal of the Collection Online project is to capture high resolution digital images of all works of art in the Collection, one of the most valuable side benefits has been the review and refinement of technical documentation for the Collection. Collating old files, confirming artists’ intentions, and incorporating this information into the Gallery’s permanent record-keeping systems, not only makes the instructions readily available for the future but also conserves both the tangible and intangible aspects of works of art. Rhiannon Walker is Associate Conservator, Collection Online, QAGOMA
  • Read

    Unlocking the Collection: A conversation with Paul Taylor

    Paul Taylor has been a member of the Gallery’s Board of Trustees and Foundation Committee since 2017 and is currently Chair of the QAGOMA Collection Online Campaign, which is the focus of this year’s Foundation Appeal. Through the Taylor Family Collection, Paul Taylor has generously helped the Gallery to secure several major artworks. These include Arthur Boyd’s Sleeping bride 1957–58 in memory of his parents, one of the most significant individual works of Australian art ever donated to the Collection; Gija artist Paddy Bedford’s Wirwirji – Police Hole 2004; and James Turrell’s Night Life2018 architectural light installation at GOMA. Lucy Whyte interviewed Paul about the campaign to digitise the Collection. What inspired you to lead the fundraising effort to help unlock the QAGOMA Collection? Digitising the Collection will transform our galleries, exhibitions, and educational and curatorial content. It will have one of the most positive impacts on audience experience and engagement that has ever been delivered by a project at QAGOMA. At the moment, only ten per cent of the Collection can be on show in the physical galleries. Once digitised, we will be able to make the Collection available online 100 per cent of the time to 100 per cent of Queenslanders. This transformation means not just the ability, for the first time, to exhibit the Collection so fully, but also to integrate online content with real-world exhibitions and link with enhanced and expanded curatorial content from QAGOMA and around the world. We will be able to deliver content that offers tailored experiences for audiences with disability, reaches remotely based audiences, fosters greater research and education, and delivers an enhanced cultural experience for all. The more I think about what is possible, after we have digitised the Collection, the more I am excited about what QAGOMA can deliver for the community. This is what has inspired me to lead the fundraising effort. In recent years, cultural institutions around the world have focused attention on making their collections more digitally accessible. How does QAGOMA’s project compare and why is the timing right to undertake the initiative now? This project, which is part of the Gallery’s larger Digital Transformation Initiative, aims to position QAGOMA as a leader in digital content creation and access so as to maintain our position as one of the world’s most visited public galleries and a destination museum. QAGOMA is renowned for the exciting ways it connects people with the power of art and ideas — as it evolves, this project will place the Gallery amongst the best in the world. In recent years, the software platforms required to expand access to the Collection have improved exponentially in both quality and interconnectivity. At the same time, the challenges the world has faced over the past year have sharply highlighted the imperative to expand QAGOMA’s digital offering. QAGOMA wants to ensure that everyone can experience the Collection and its interpretative content from any location, at any time. Institutions and corporations around the world are currently examining their digital infrastructure and strategy and QAGOMA is no different. This is a project of huge benefits and its time is now. What would you tell someone considering giving to the Appeal? When I contribute to a charity or a fundraising campaign, I am always focused on the size of the impact for the money I am donating. We are hoping to raise $5 million to digitise the QAGOMA Collection, which we believe will deliver tremendous benefits to the community. The Appeal will help all Queenslanders access their world-class Collection and will allow us to transform and enhance audience engagement and experience. QAGOMA is the soul of the cultural and artistic community in Queensland so I encourage everyone to consider donating to the Appeal. Lucy Whyte is Bequest and Communications Officer, QAGOMA Foundation. She interviewed Paul Taylor in March 2021. Featured image: Paul Taylor with Victor Meertens’s sculptural work Delvig 1990, a gift of the Brisbane Convention and Exhibition Centre 1999, installed for digitisation in Gallery 14, QAG, March 2021 / Photograph: Katie Bennett © QAGOMA
  • Read

    Unlocking the Collection: Making artworks discoverable

    The QAGOMA Digital Transformation Initiative is a wide-reaching program that aims to position the Gallery as leader in digital content creation. Several years in the making, the project was greatly accelerated by the COVID-19 lockdown. Here, Morgan Strong demystifies this substantial undertaking. So, what does ‘Digital Transformation’ mean? Frequently, this is an umbrella term for updating software, digitising processes, replacing manual workflows, leveraging new opportunities . . . but really, it’s simply about integrating digital into all areas of what an organisation does. In the Gallery’s context, and for our audiences, this means three main things: making our Collection more available and accessible; embracing digital as a communication tool via virtual and digital channels; and aligning what we do as an organisation with the many opportunities afforded by being digital. Watch as we capture Nindityo Adipurnomo’s ‘Introversion’ We can represent artworks at such a resolution that when you see the work on a device, you’ll be able to see it in a lot more detail than ever before. The Collection will be more easily discoverable and offer you similar works for inspiration. We can share multiple voices and interpretations and make them more accessible. A digital transformation for the Gallery means bringing the Collection to members of communities where a digital connection can bridge an existing gap. Also, back of house, it means more processes can be automated, so there’s more time to do the important work of curating, designing, expanding and publishing on the Collection, and to reflect on and embrace what art means to the state. To make this happen, we’re embarking on this major project of digitising the Collection, which is the focus of this year’s QAGOMA Foundation Appeal. If we have digital content for the whole Collection, the publishing capabilities are endless. The ability to cross-pollinate this data with other sources will enable new and novel meaning. We are also embarking on improving the administrative systems that we rely on to do our jobs: currently, our Collection Management, Digital Asset Management, Constituent Relationship Management and internal collaboration systems have either been upgraded and are in the process of being rolled out, or they’re in active development. Watch as we capture Joan Miró’s ‘Monument’ Joan Miró, Spain 1893-1983 / Monument cast 1970 / Bronze with black patina; base of welded steel, painted black / 289.5 x 103 x 65cm / Purchased 1983. Queensland Art Gallery Foundation / Collection: Queensland Art Gallery | Gallery of Modern Art / © Joan Miró/Succession Miró/ADAGP/Copyright Agency / Timelapse: Lee Wilkes © QAGOMA Perhaps most importantly, the Digital Transformation Initiative has also resulted in new products and new digital ways of sharing our Collection: during the lockdown of 2020, we launched an early ‘beta’ or experimental Collection Search site to gather feedback in determining its most important elements and to show how we can rapidly publish and iterate on the artworks in the Collection. We have developed new media players that will allow you to see the x-ray and infrared layers of artworks; started creating maps of where works were created; and cross-linked Collection works with related videos, blogs and Artlines articles. We are building mobile tools so you can easily access this content even as you stand in front of the physical object. And we’ve only just begun. Over the next few years, this foundational work will start making its way into the QAGOMA website, and our digitisation output will start meaning we can produce more and more valuable content for our audiences. It’s an exciting time. Morgan Strong is Digital Transformation Manager, QAGOMA Featured image: Photographer Merinda Campbell in the process of capturing Introversion (April the twenty-first) 1995-96 by Nindityo Adipurnomo for the Gallery’s digitisation project / Photograph: Lee Wilkes © QAGOMA